Friday, January 17, 2025

From Informal Jobs to Vision 2035: Brunei’s Workforce Struggles Continue


By Malai Hassan Othman


BRUNEI DARUSSALAM, JANUARY 2025: Brunei’s labour market challenges remain a significant roadblock to achieving Vision 2035. 

 

With 11,700 unemployed citizens and over 86,700 informal workers, the nation’s ability to create a resilient and sustainable workforce is under scrutiny. 

 

This follow-up delves deeper into the realities behind the numbers, shedding light on the voices of those affected and exploring practical solutions.

 

Informal Jobs: A Short-Term Solution with Lasting Impacts

Informal jobs often lack contracts, benefits, or job security, leaving workers vulnerable to exploitation and financial instability.

 

These jobs also limit workers' ability to contribute to TAP and SPK, further jeopardising their future financial security. 

 

Simplifying business registration processes and ensuring access to TAP and SPK for informal workers could be game-changers. 

 

Offering incentives like supplemental income protection and extended benefits could encourage formalisation, enabling more sustainable career paths.

 

An independent observer noted, "Formalizing informal work is essential for a stable economy. Without it, we risk an underutilized workforce and limited social protections." 

 

The informal sector, comprising over 100,087 workers, provides temporary relief but lacks long-term stability. 

 

For Siti, an informal worker who lives paycheck to paycheck, emergencies can bring devastating financial consequences. 

 

Meanwhile, Brunei employs 73,845 work pass holders, highlighting the untapped potential of its unemployed workforce. 

 

Better workforce management could empower unemployed locals to fill roles currently occupied by foreign labour, reducing dependency and strengthening the local economy.

 

Countries like Malaysia and Indonesia offer valuable lessons. 

 

Malaysia’s token taxation model encourages small-scale entrepreneurs to formalise their businesses, making it easier for them to access financial resources. 

 

Similarly, Indonesia’s flat 0.5% tax on gross turnover for micro-enterprises has successfully integrated informal businesses into the formal economy. 


An economist commented, "The key lies in blending formalisation with accessible incentives, ensuring that businesses see the value in transitioning without fear of excessive costs."

 

Voices from the Ground: Stories of Struggle

The personal accounts of Bruneians reveal the harsh realities of the workforce. 

 

One worker lamented, “Banyak factors yang menghalang for us untuk berjaya..telampau banyak rintangan, apabila berjaya terpaksa membagi makan banyak mulut untuk terus hidup.” This highlights the emotional and financial strain faced by families.

 

Rahim, a university graduate, has been searching for work for over a year despite his qualifications. 

 

Siti, an informal worker, shared, “If I fall sick, I don’t earn anything. With this job, we don’t even have the opportunity to invest in our future and retirement in TAP and SPK, let alone save for our kids’ education.” 

 

These experiences reflect the plight of the 69,200 informal workers in the services sector, as reported in the Labour Force Survey (LFS) 2023.

 

A policy expert remarked, "We need to address the root causes, not just the symptoms. 


Aligning education with market needs and fostering innovation in small businesses can unlock new opportunities for locals."

 

Economic Diversification: A Necessity for Growth

Brunei’s reliance on oil and gas poses a significant vulnerability. Efforts to diversify into sectors like technology, tourism, and agriculture have progressed slowly. 

 

The CSPS Job Futures study warns that without automation and AI adoption, economic stagnation will persist.

 

Public-private partnerships could foster innovation and growth

 

Providing grants, low-interest loans, and mentorship to startups could stimulate entrepreneurship. 

 

Lessons from Malaysia and Indonesia highlight the value of robust ecosystems for small businesses, which can create sustainable job opportunities while reducing reliance on foreign labour. 

 

The Financing for Sustainable Development Framework emphasises the importance of mobilising resources for sustainable and inclusive growth. 

 

It highlights that "investment in dynamic and people-centred economies is key to fostering innovation and creating productive employment."

 

Leadership and Action: Paving the Way for Vision 2035

 

Realizing Wawasan 2035 requires decisive leadership and collaboration across all sectors. 

 

As one community leader remarked, “While the journey is tough, our shared resilience and determination can transform these challenges into opportunities.”

 

Key priorities must include upskilling the workforce, formalizing informal jobs, and diversifying the economy. 

 

Strong collaboration between government, private sectors, and communities will be essential to creating a prosperous future for all citizens. 

 

An independent report stressed, "Managerial capital, which refers to the skills, expertise, and efficiency of management across all sectors, is a critical missing component in developing economies like Brunei. 

 

For example, effective managerial leadership can optimise resource allocation, enhance workforce productivity, and drive innovation. 

 

In the context of small and medium enterprises (SMEs), a lack of managerial expertise often leads to inefficiencies, limited scalability, and missed opportunities. 

 

Bridging this gap can empower local businesses to compete regionally and internationally while fostering a more robust economic ecosystem."

 

A Call to Action

Brunei stands at a crossroads. Leaders must act boldly to address the labour market crisis. 

 

Vision 2035 can be a transformative milestone or a missed opportunity. 

 

For Rahim, Siti, and countless others, the stakes couldn’t be higher. The time to act is now. Brunei’s future depends on it.

 

Imagine a Brunei where every citizen has access to stable employment, where businesses thrive on innovation, and where economic growth benefits all. 

 

That vision is achievable—but only with decisive action today. (MHO/01/2025)

 

Monday, January 13, 2025

A New Hope for Brunei’s Telcos: Prompt Action, Persistent Issues

"Caught in the roaming trap again—despite switching off my phone! My recent bill shock exposes persistent flaws in Brunei’s telecommunications system. As DST takes swift action to address my case, the bigger question looms: are telcos doing enough to prevent such issues for everyone? Dive into the Telcos Tell All podcast and the growing public demand for reform."


By Malai Hassan Othman

 

JANUARY 2025: In a positive development, DST recently addressed my complaint regarding a bill shock incident with commendable promptness.

 

After a thorough investigation, they acknowledged the charges and agreed to waive a significant portion, leaving only a fair and acceptable amount to be paid. 

 

Additionally, DST informed me that they are reviewing their roaming charges with international telcos to establish fairer rates. 

 

They also suggested reducing my credit limit from BND400 to BND100 and turning off my roaming mode, which I can now activate as needed via the My DST app.

 

I have expressed my appreciation for DST’s prompt action in addressing my concerns and implementing these measures to help prevent future bill shocks.

 

Meanwhile, DST informed me that my January 2025 bill reflected roaming service usage again, which I had suspected might happen. 

 

On 10th January, during a quick trip to Miri, I deliberately switched off my phone upon leaving the Brunei checkpoint at Sungai Tujuh to avoid being unnecessarily charged for roaming services again.

 

To further minimize risks, I opted not to use my pocket Wi-Fi, which would have required me to turn on my phone and disable roaming and data mode. 

 

Although it was inconvenient to remain offline for the duration of my short trip, I decided it was a safer choice, despite the worry of potentially missing important calls or messages.

 

To my surprise, my phone mysteriously turned on without my intervention when I arrived at the Brunei checkpoint in the evening. 

 

Upon retrieving it from the car compartment, intending to switch it back on after re-entering Brunei at the Sungai Tujuh checkpoint, I discovered it was already connected to a Malaysian network. 

 

DST assured me they would adjust the charges to a more reasonable amount, though I firmly believe no charges should apply, given the unexplained activation. 

 

This recurring issue highlights the persistent challenges with effectively managing roaming settings and preventing unexpected charges.

 

This perplexing situation highlights the ongoing challenges of roaming settings and underscores the need for further improvements in managing such issues. 

 

While DST’s swift response is encouraging, such measures must be extended to all customers facing similar challenges. 

 

This is not just about my case—it is about ensuring fairness and justice for all customers. 

 

As we consider the broader implications of these challenges, it is worth revisiting the Telcos Tell All podcast, which brought these issues to public discourse. 

 

Hosted by Jenny Malai Ali, the podcast aimed to address public concerns while also highlighting systemic shortcomings in the telecommunications sector.



Podcast Highlights: Public Concerns  Raised

The Telcos Tell All podcast provided a platform for telco executives to address public concerns. 

 

Jenny facilitated discussions on critical issues, with persistent complaints about billing inconsistencies, unexplained charges, and roaming fees dominating the conversation. 

 

While the session aimed to portray Brunei’s telecommunications as evolving, it fell short of fully exploring or resolving the public's grievances. 

 

Executives shared insights into their operational challenges, yet sentiments widely expressed across public forums and social media emphasised a pressing need for stronger consumer protections. 

 

These frustrations have fueled calls for real-time alerts, transparent billing practices, and subscription safeguards to protect users from financial shocks.

 

Recurring Issues: The Public’s  Perspective 

While DST’s response to my complaint was exemplary, many customers continued to express dissatisfaction with unresolved issues. 

 

Concerns about excessive roaming charges and allegations of predatory billing practices persist in public debates. 

 

One user remarked, “Being charged $50 per gigabyte for exceeding data is not just unfair—it feels extortionate.” 

 

Another added, “While Imagine apologises for app bugs, DST blames us for not monitoring usage, and Progresif offers vague advice to ‘be more aware.’ Where are the real solutions?” 

 

These frustrations align with my earlier Kopi Talk with MHO column, which detailed similar grievances. 

 

Customers' growing impatience with the lack of comprehensive reforms highlights the urgent need for telcos to shift from reactive measures to proactive solutions.

 

The Role of UNN: A Centralized  Bottleneck?

UNN’s centralised model, while praised for advancing infrastructure improvements, has been criticised for inefficiencies that exacerbate consumer frustrations. 

 

Acting CEO Chris Phan, like other executives, attributed some complaints to customer behaviour and technical complexities. 

 

Critics argue this deflection shifts accountability away from systemic issues, compounding the public’s dissatisfaction.

 

A Call for  Reform

As state-owned enterprises (SOEs), Brunei’s telcos have an opportunity to align their corporate social responsibility (CSR) strategies with the principles of Adil Laila Bahagia and Adil dan Berehsan—core tenets of His Majesty Sultan’s governance. 

 

A comparative look at neighbouring countries reveals actionable insights. 

 

For example, Malaysia’s telcos, such as Maxis and Digi, offer real-time notifications and customisable credit limits, which have significantly reduced bill shock cases. 

 

Similarly, Singapore’s Singtel and StarHub emphasise transparent billing by providing itemised charges and alerts for data overages.

 

By incorporating these practices and values into their operations, Brunei’s telcos can rebuild trust and demonstrate their commitment to fairness, justice, and customer welfare. 

 

Industry experts recommend several key reforms:

 

  • Real-Time Alerts: Notify users nearing data or credit limits to avoid bill shocks.

  • Transparent Billing: Provide itemised bills with clear explanations of charges.

  • Subscription Safeguards: Implement double-confirmation systems for paid services.

  • Customer Education: Initiate programs to improve digital literacy and service usage.

  • Independent Oversight: Establish a regulatory body to ensure accountability.

 

Conclusion: Rebuilding  Trust

DST’s swift action in resolving my complaint is a step in the right direction, but it must be part of a broader and sustained effort.

 

The Telcos Tell All podcast highlighted the sector’s aspirations for transparency while exposing glaring gaps in accountability. 

 

For Brunei’s telecommunications sector to embody Vision 2035’s ideals of fairness and transparency, it must address customer grievances directly and consistently. 

 

Without meaningful reforms, telcos risk eroding public trust in their services and the institutions they represent. (MHO/01/2025)

Sunday, January 12, 2025

800 Complaints a Month: The True Cost of DST’s Billing Practices

 

Kopi Talk with MHO

 

As a loyal DST customer who has subscribed to their $80 monthly package for nearly three decades, I have always counted on them for reliable and fair services. 

 

Throughout Brunei's evolving digital landscape, DST has been my go-to provider. 

 

However, my recent experience with unexplained roaming charges has left me deeply disappointed and questioning the trust I’ve placed in them for so long. 

 

The Bill That Raised Eyebrows

 

On December 26, 2024, I travelled to Miri, taking every precaution to avoid roaming charges. 

 

I had my mobile data and roaming settings switched off, relying solely on a mobile WiFi device. 

 

Yet, when my January bill arrived, I was shocked to see a staggering B$320.16 in roaming data charges. 

 

The timing of these charges was perplexing; despite spending nearly 12 hours in Miri, all charges occurred within a very short period. Why then? What triggered these charges when my phone was set to block roaming entirely? 

 

Breaking Down the Charges



 

The details on my bill were equally baffling: 

 

  • Multiple charges of B$13.92 for data sessions as small as 781 KB. 

 

  • A total of 22 roaming sessions within minutes, amounting to over B$320.

 

To put this in perspective, the charges for just a few minutes of data usage exceeded the total cost of my entire trip to Miri. 

 

Other customers have reported eerily similar experiences on social media:


  • “I didn’t touch my phone for three hours while abroad and still got charged BND 70! Daylight robbery!” 

  •  “DST charged me over BND 300 for roaming data in a few minutes. Each session was BND 13 for barely any data!”

 

These are not isolated cases; they indicate a systemic issue within DST’s billing processes. 

 

Critical Questions

 

This experience raises critical questions about DST’s practices: 

 

  • How accurate is DST’s billing system? Are customers being charged for data they didn’t use? 

  •  Why did these charges occur during such a short window, despite my phone being configured to block roaming? 

  • Could this indicate flaws in DST’s system that unfairly penalize customers?

 

The lack of transparency and safeguards leaves customers vulnerable to unexplained charges and bill shocks. This is not just disappointing; it’s deeply unsettling. 

 

Ethical Responsibilities of a State-Owned Enterprise

 

As a state-owned enterprise, DST is expected to uphold higher standards in its business practices. 

 

As a national telecommunications provider, it should lead by example in customer care, setting benchmarks for transparency, fairness, and accountability. 

 

This aligns with the concept of Adil Laila Bahagia—justice that brings happiness to all stakeholders. 

 

This principle, rooted in the governance philosophy of His Majesty the Sultan, demands fairness and accountability in serving the public.

 

DST’s CEO, Radin Sufri, candidly admitted during the Telcos Tell All podcast with Jenny Malai Ali on October 16, 2024, that 40% of the 2,000 monthly complaints, translating to approximately 800 unhappy customers every month, pertain to billing issues, including unexplained roaming charges and subscription fees for services that users claim they never opted into. 

 

During the discussion, Radin’s remarks appeared to downplay these concerns, suggesting that user behaviour significantly contributes to the problems. 

 

This indirect shift of responsibility frustrated many customers who expected concrete solutions instead of justification. 

 

Such an attitude reinforces the perception that DST is more focused on managing optics than addressing systemic issues, leaving their status quo unchallenged.

 

Transparency, fairness, and customer welfare should be the pillars of DST’s business model, ensuring that all its dealings align with Islamic values and principles of good governance. 

 

The principles of Maqasid Syariah—which emphasize the preservation of religion, life, intellect, lineage, and wealth—further underscore the ethical and moral obligations of a state-owned enterprise like DST. 

 

Engaging in practices that result in unjust billing or unfair financial burdens risks crossing into the realm of haram, as such actions contradict the expectations of justice and fairness in business transactions (muamalat). 

 

However, their continued reliance on reactive responses rather than proactive reforms leaves much to be desired. 

 

Lessons from Global Precedents

 

To understand the gravity of this issue, let’s look at how similar cases have been addressed globally: 

 

  • Vodafone (Australia, 2016): Complaints about misleading roaming charges led to refunds after an investigation by the ACCC. 

 

  •  AT&T (United States, 2014): Fined $105 million by the FCC for unauthorized roaming charges, with customers refunded and billing practices overhauled. 

 

  •  O2 (United Kingdom, 2020): Overcharged customers received refunds after O2 committed to clearer billing practices. 
 
  • Rogers (Canada, 2018): Bill shock complaints led to regulatory intervention, forcing Rogers to cap roaming charges and implement transparent pricing.

 

These cases highlight the importance of accountability and customer protection—values central to Islamic business ethics, yet seemingly lacking in DST’s current practices. 

 

Constructive Solutions for DST

 

As someone who has supported DST for almost three decades, I believe it’s time for them to take these concerns seriously. Here are practical steps they can take to rebuild trust: 


  • Real-Time Usage Alerts: Notify customers when they reach 50%, 80%, and 100% of their data limits. 

  • Billing Caps: Enforce a maximum cap on roaming charges, similar to international practices. 

  • Transparent Pricing: Display per-unit pricing for roaming data on bills and usage trackers. 

  • Audit Billing Systems: Conduct an independent review to ensure fairness and eliminate unjust or duplicate charges.

  • Proactive Engagement: Address the root causes of complaints and engage with customers to rebuild trust.

 

Let’s Talk About It

 

As someone who has remained loyal to DST despite recurring issues, I am disappointed that such problems persist. 

 

To my readers: Have you experienced similar issues with DST’s roaming charges? 

 

Share your stories with me—let's make our voices heard. 

 

Together, we can urge DST to align its practices with global standards, the principles of Adil Laila Bahagia, and the ethical framework of Maqasid Syariah. 

 

This is not just about one bill or one customer—it’s about holding service providers accountable and advocating for change that benefits everyone. 

 

DST has the opportunity to be a model of ethical and customer-centric business practices, setting the standard for fairness and transparency in the telecommunications sector. Let’s hope they seize it. (MHO/01/2025)